2020 Halloween Costume Contest
Enter 2020 Costume Contest
PB & J Costume
by Stephanie
PB & J Costume
by Jamie
Peanut Butter & Jelly Costume
by Mona

Peanut Butter & Jelly Costume

Rate this costume:

55 votes
20 comments  ·  add a comment 
Peanut Butter & Jelly Costume

A little 'fluff'

More views: (click to enlarge)
Photo #1 - A little 'fluff' Photo #2 - Fully functional for trick-or-treating Photo #3 - The 'jars' just before arm-holes Photo #4 - Jelly layout Photo #5 - Peanut Butter layout Photo #6 - The materials
Costume type:  Costumes for Kids
Category:Halloween Costumes

This homemade costume for kids entered our 2012 Halloween Costume Contest.

A word from Kim, the 'PB&J' costume creator:

Its fun to come up with different ideas for twin costumes to shake things up a bit, and my girls love peanut butter & jelly sandwiches, so, why not let them be PB&J for halloween? Gabrielle is the Jiff and Grace is the Smuckers. So much fun trying to figure how i was going to make these and keep the shape of a jar, but with a wire wreath circular frame and a few yards of felt, anything is possible! For the actual trick or treating, I joined in the fun with a little Fluff of my own :)

Rating: 4.7 of 5. Votes: 55

55 votes
Pin It


#1 comment by Mary October 5, 2012

Super cute! Is mick a butter knife?

#2 comment by Sue Downing October 5, 2012

I love it!!!!!!! They look so cute including mom!

#3 comment by Tammy October 6, 2012

Awesome I love it! You all look great!

#4 comment by aj loves crunchy peanut butter October 6, 2012

Hahaha.... Fluff. Great job!

#5 comment by Diane October 6, 2012

I've always loved peanut butter and jelly, but now I like it even more!

#6 comment by Renae October 7, 2012

Your so talented, love it!

#7 comment by Michelle October 8, 2012

They are adorable! Great idea Mom!

#8 comment by Kristine Garner October 8, 2012

SO cute, Kim! Ingenious actually....LOVE seeing 'different' costumes (AND home-made ones) come to my door on Halloween (they always get 2 pieces of candy over store bought!). PJ&J fan!

#9 comment by Tracey October 9, 2012

Sheer Genius!! This is what Halloween is all about. The girls will look back on this when they are older and give their Mom a big 'ol hug for being so creative and getting into the spirit!

#10 comment by gp October 15, 2012

me and my boyfriend did this and we used hula hoops as the circle came out super cute 2 years ago

#11 comment by Deidre October 15, 2013

I love this!!! I have 2 year old boy/girl twins. Where can I order this...I am not crafty, nor have time!

#12 comment by Sarah Morrow September 21, 2014

Hi Kim,

Can I borrow peanut butter and fluff or get some pointers from you? I'm the entertainment at the "what the fluff" festival in the city where fluff was born: Somerville mass exit weekend and need an outfit for me and my bass player! Thanks for helping me get to looking as awesome as you and your adorbs kids!


#13 comment by Melissa September 23, 2014


Is the Marshmallow Fluff shirt made from felt too? Last year my girls were Ketchup and Mustard...totally doing this for them this year :)

#14 comment by Kim Giesing September 23, 2014

Hi everyone! Thank you for the lovely compliments!

Everything I made was using felt - I usually trace out the design on paper first, then I hold the paper up to a window and trace the reverse pattern. Then, I trace it thru the paper (using a pen, pressing hard) onto the felt. This way, when I cut it out, any extra markings are on the backside - hopefully that made sense. The biggest thing was just getting the logo from my old pal, google, and finding matching felt colors :)

#15 comment by Amy October 19, 2014

How did you do logos snd lettering?

#16 comment by Kim G October 19, 2014

I bought the felt letters and I drew the logos from a picture I found online of the jars :)

#17 comment by Faith November 17, 2014

Is there instructions on how to make this? This is the best one I've seen!

#18 comment by bn September 27, 2016

How do you make the costume?

#19 comment by Tina September 26, 2017

How can I get a Smuckers outfit?

#20 comment by Alyson October 19, 2019

Hey... quick question, how did you get the jif logo to look so good?

Add Your Comment

* Comment: 
* Your Name: 
* Your Email: